There could already be trouble in paradise for Casey Anthony and her married beau.
Two different women came forward to say 48-year-old Tyson Ray Rhodes is using the dating app Hinge to try to hook up — days after The Post revealed that the infamous “tot mom” has been having an affair with him.
Rhodes blew up his 20-year marriage to the mother of his two sons to be with Anthony, and she moved from Florida to Tennessee earlier this year for their relationship, sources said.
Casey Anthony and Tyson Rhodes seen leaving a condo in Tennessee together on Sept. 4, 2024.LP Media for NY Post
Rhodes has been actively using the dating app Hinge despite his relationship with Anthony, two women told The Post.LP Media for NY Post
The Post has reviewed screenshots of conversations between the women and an account that appears to be Rhodes’ profile on Hinge, where he says he’s single and looking for love.
In one conversation, a woman confronted Rhodes with The Post story about Anthony. “Did you know you’re in The New York Post for dating Casey Anthony?” the woman asked.
“Yep,” Rhodes responded.
She declined to go out with him after he admitted his backstory.
A second woman said Rhodes told her that he was divorced. Sources said he is still legally married to his wife of 22 years.
Both of the women have been messaging Rhodes for some time, including exchanges within the past week.
Tyson Rhodes (with his wife and kids) has been seeing Anthony since January.Obtained by NY Post
“So he’s still married and he is dating Casey Anthony on the side, but he’s still on dating apps,” one of the women said. “I’m not just a ‘no,’ I’m a ‘hell no.’ He is absolutely not the right guy for me.”
Rhodes has not responded to multiple messages seeking comment.
Anthony, 38, has been dating Rhodes since January after they met in a South Florida gym. Earlier this year, the married dad of two grown sons moved from South Florida to Tennessee. Shortly after the move, he dropped a bombshell on the mother of his children when he told her he wanted a divorce.
He has yet to file the paperwork, but family sources said that she was “blindsided” by the news.
Anthony soon followed him to Tennessee, renting a luxury apartment near his family home. The Post obtained photos of Anthony and Rhodes together at her apartment on Wednesday, when they went golfing together before heading to the gym.
“She sees potential in him,” an Anthony friend told The Post last week. “She wants to see where this goes.”
In 2008, when she was just 21 years old, Anthony was a single mother living with her parents when her 2-year-old daughter, Caylee, vanished without a trace.
The little girl had been missing for more than a month before Casey’s mother, Cindy, called 911 to report the disappearance.
A Department of Corrections spokeswoman once called Casey Anthony “the most hated woman in America.”AP
During a nationwide hunt for the missing toddler, Casey Anthony was arrested after police caught her in several lies, including claiming that Caylee had been kidnapped by a nanny, Zenaida Fernandez Gonzalez.
Police soon learned that Anthony had spent the previous month dancing on tables and partying with friends — and not looking for her missing daughter.
Six months later, Caylee’s remains were found in a wooded area near the Anthony family home. Her cause of death could not be determined, but Casey was charged with first-degree murder.
Caylee Anthony was just 2 when she died.AP
Anthony’s 2011 murder trial was a media circus.
An estimated 40 million Americans watched at least part of the trial — and the verdict was watched by nearly 100 million people worldwide.
The prosecution alleged Anthony killed her little girl so that she could party with friends and have sex with her boyfriend.
Casey Anthony told friends that she doesn’t care if her boyfriend is married.LP Media for NY Post
The defense countered that Anthony was a loving mother and that Caylee had drowned in the family pool. In the end, Anthony was infamously acquitted of murder charges — although she was convicted of four counts of lying to law enforcement. She was released from jail in July 2011.
Despite her infamy, Anthony seems unbothered about the scandal that will arise from dating a married man.
“She doesn’t care if he’s married or not,” a pal of Anthony’s told The Post last week. “I was like, ‘Casey, a married guy?’ and she just laughed and said, ‘Oh shut up, I’m living the life I want.’”
